Heretic review: a must-see thriller with a killer lead performance

Heretic is simply a location of cards. It is simply a playful, thoughtfully crafted building that — overmuch for illustration its talkative antagonist — is yet afloat of air. All it would return is 1 beardown gust of upwind aliases a azygous anemic nexus to origin Heretic to autumn wholly successful connected itself. It needs thing beardown capable to protect itself from that benignant of weakness successful bid to enactment standing, and Heretic thankfully finds precisely that successful Hugh Grant. A starring man of a cardinal different, yet akin shades, Grant has spent nan past 10 years of his profession gleefully tap-dancing retired of measurement pinch nan mostly rom-com rhythms of his earlier profession successful bid to play roguish villains, cheating husbands, murder-obsessed politicians, and moreover a snarky, orange-skinned Oompa Loompa.

He has cemented himself arsenic 1 of nan astir reliable segment stealers of this decade and nan last, but extracurricular of a fewer TV roles, Grant has recovered his caller successes successful supporting parts. Heretic breaks that shape by giving Grant nan starring domiciled he deserves astatine this shape of his profession — 1 that allows him to usage each instrumentality successful his toolbox. In Heretic, a deliciously mean helping of belief scary that feels for illustration a modern Grimms’ fairy tale, he is some nan charismatic middle-aged professor and nan witch hiding nan human-sized oven successful his kitchen. He is besides a stammering, affable, twinkle-eyed, and hunched-shouldered man of immense charm who often resembles nan generation-defining rom-com prima viewers erstwhile knew Grant to be.

A24

Heretic uses that familiar, good-humored charm to astonishingly awesome effect. Here, it is employed not to woo viewers aliases a female emotion interest, but to disarm nan 2 young women, a brace of naive Mormon missionaries named Sister Barnes (Sophie Thatcher) and Sister Paxton (Chloe East), who travel knocking connected his doorway 1 rainy evening. They do truthful successful nan hopes of converting Grant’s reclusive, approachable Mr. Reed to their Mormon faith, and are initially delighted erstwhile their proposition is met pinch unfastened arms and a funny mind. Not agelong aft Reed has led them into his location connected nan committedness that his woman is baking a blueberry pastry successful nan room offscreen, however, do Paxton and Barnes statesman to fishy that they’ve walked into a much sinister trap than they could person ever imagined.

A24

The movie builds to this turning constituent pinch assurance and considered style. Its opening scene, a speech astir condom sizes betwixt Barnes and Paxton, marks nan debased constituent of Scott Beck and Bryan Woods’ screenplay and plays up its female leads’ obliviousness astir nan mechanics of activity to a laughable degree. The scene’s speech and nan ocular pun waiting astatine nan extremity of its first changeable clumsily foreshadow nan darkly funny comedic tone that Woods and Beck spell connected to inject acold much efficaciously passim Heretic‘s 2nd and 3rd acts. Fortunately, nan penning and directing duo don’t hold agelong to bring Thatcher and East’s missionaries face-to-face pinch Grant’s manipulator. They dedicate conscionable capable minutes to nan awkward drudgery of Barnes and Paxton’s missionary activity for Reed’s excitement astir speaking pinch them to enactment arsenic an initial, effective jolt to nan system.

Heretic clicks into sharper spot erstwhile Reed originates deliberately pushing against his guests’ belief convictions. It’s successful this series that 3 things go clear: The brilliance of Grant’s casting, nan crackling imaginable of Beck and Woods’ dialogue, and nan precision of Chung Chung-hoon’s cinematography. Beck and Woods’ erstwhile directorial efforts, which see 2023’s sci-fi movie 65, didn’t denote them arsenic filmmakers pinch a peculiarly powerful ocular style. In that respect, Heretic is simply a marked improvement. Many of nan thriller’s astir unnerving scenes, including Reed’s first quasi-interrogation of Paxton and Barnes, impact agelong monologues and back-and-forth exchanges. Beck, Woods, and Chung elevate these sequences pinch well-timed close-ups and revolving pans that adhd a dynamism they mightiness different lack, pass nan underlying malevolence of Grant’s villain, and found an uncomfortable intimacy betwixt Heretic‘s 3 leads that is reinforced by nan inescapable quality of Reed’s labyrinthine home.

A24

Once Barnes and Paxton travel to nan horrifying realization that they’re trapped, Grant’s Reed is fixed each nan support he needs to shed 1 tegument for another. He exchanges his friendly, neighborly destruction for that of a wannabe teacher who gives deranged, rehearsed speeches that comparison nan creation of popular taste artifacts for illustration Radiohead’s Creep and Jar-Jar Binks to nan iterative origins of nan world’s “modern” religions. There isn’t capable constituent successful what nan man says to punctual overmuch compelling reflection connected nan portion of viewers, and nan aforesaid is existent of Heretic‘s wholly surface-level, evident thoughts connected belief itself. The measurement successful which nan movie reaches its eventual points is, however, ever immensely entertaining. Beck and Woods, who collapsed into nan mainstream by penning nan original book for A Quiet Place, person an knowing of melodramatic escalation and hostility that makes their activity thrilling to watch whenever it is connected afloat display.

The duo besides knows erstwhile to supply relief, and successful Grant they find a performer tin of transitioning seamlessly betwixt pitch-black comedic levity and melodramatic intensity. As Reed, Grant transforms his iconic, boyish smirk into a conniving cheshire grin — 1 of Hollywood’s astir charming rom-com smiles becomes a toothy model into nan predatory quality that his characteristic does his champion to disguise beneath courtesy and cleverness. Opposite him, Thatcher brings a steadiness to Barnes that stands successful stark opposition to nan frazzled desperation of East’s Paxton, and that helps nan 2 characters look arsenic worthwhile counters to their maniacal captor. While Beck and Woods ne'er make nan correction of ignoring nan comic absurdity of Heretic‘s communicative and its villain’s games, nan duo do return nan threat that Reed poses to his younger female prisoners earnestly capable to springiness nan movie nan nerve-shredding separator that it and its group pieces need.

A24

Where Reed’s life-and-death games yet lead some falls short of nan first expectations that Heretic sets and exceeds them. There is very small existent testing of Barnes and Paxton’s religion progressive successful their tormenter’s plans, and nan conclusions that Reed offers astir nan “one existent religion” are simple astatine best. At nan aforesaid time, Heretic digs deeper into a benignant of devious depravity that is genuinely shocking astatine times — and not slightest because of really unwaveringly Beck, Woods, and Grant perpetrate to subverting nan latter’s usually endearing surface persona. The logistics of its last enactment only make consciousness wrong nan film’s cockeyed reality, and respective of its last twists frighten to autumn isolated nether nan lightest interrogation.

The superficiality of Heretic‘s ideas does small to hamper nan film’s effectiveness, though. This is simply a thriller told pinch exceptional, gripping power and a near-perfect mastery of tone. It unfolds astatine specified a propulsive, assured gait that it leaves small room for you to do thing much than consciousness nan visceral effects of its filmmaking and nan expanding claustrophobia of its interior world arsenic nan full, suffocating cruelty of its villain’s scheme is revealed. With 3 beardown lead performances and one, successful particular, that dares you to look away, Heretic besides grounds its communicative successful an enthralling conflict betwixt a trio of very different, but likewise tin performers.

It is some ironic and miraculous that nan 1 point Heretic accrues early connected moreover much than hostility and dread is faith, if not successful nan potency of its ideas, past successful its expertise to support your bosom complaint up and your eyes glued to its many, shadowy images. Heretic proves your belief successful it to beryllium well-founded — moreover arsenic it explores each nan measurement to its past framework whether aliases not nan devout religion practiced by its missionary protagonists takes distant much from them than it gives. Heretic, for its part, offers astir arsenic overmuch crossed its 111 minutes arsenic you could dream — aliases believe — for. It’s 1 of nan astir vicious and exhilarating thrillers of nan year.

Heretic is now playing successful theaters.